Hiring your nonprofit’s first employee? Here’s what you need to know

by | Jul 24, 2023

When hiring your first employee at a growing nonprofit, it is crucial to understand the essential steps to hiring. Ultimately it involves finding the right individual to propel the organization forward while navigating the complexities of the hiring process. It can be overwhelming. In this article, we will explore the questions you should carefully consider during this hiring process

First Things First: Do You Need to Hire?

Hiring is a significant decision that requires thoughtful consideration and financial preparation. Before hiring a new employee for your organization, it’s crucial to ensure it’s the right move. Evaluate your organization’s growth and workload demands, then pinpoint areas where you need additional support. Understand your budget and resources to ensure you can sustain the new hire long-term. Consult with your accountant to determine if it’s the right time financially and to understand the potential impacts on your financial stability.

Definition: What Will the Role and Responsibilities Be? 

Before beginning the hiring process, it’s crucial to define the role and responsibilities of the new employee. This involves crafting a comprehensive job description outlining tasks, duties, and expectations. Be sure to note the qualifications, skills, technical expertise, and experience needed to excel in the role, as well as the values and attributes that align with your organization’s culture, goals, and mission. By establishing a well-defined position and identifying the necessary qualifications and cultural fit, you’ll be better equipped to attract and hire the ideal candidate.

Establish your Nonprofit Hiring Process

Streamline the journey to finding the right employee and increase the likelihood of a successful recruitment outcome by outlining and establishing a transparent hiring process. Start by defining the key steps and setting clear timelines: What needs to be done, and when? Establish milestones for tasks such as creating the job description, advertising the position, conducting interviews, and making a final decision. 

Additionally, determine how you will attract potential candidates. Consider utilizing job boards, social media platforms, and your organization’s website to reach a broader audience. A well-defined plan and timeline will keep the process on track and prevent unnecessary delays.

5 Tangible Steps to Hiring your first Nonprofit Employee

Create a Well-Written Job Posting

Create a compelling and accurate job posting that conveys the nonprofit’s mission, vision, and values to attract candidates passionate about the cause. Highlight the qualifications, responsibilities, and benefits of the role to draw in individuals who align with the organization’s objectives and possess the required skills. A well-crafted job posting that communicates the nonprofit’s purpose and provides a comprehensive overview of the position will attract top talent and lead to a successful and purpose-driven hiring process.

Selecting and Interviewing Candidates 

The next step in the hiring process is reviewing resumes and applications to shortlist candidates. Once narrowed down, conduct initial interviews to assess skills, experience, and values alignment with the organization. Further, evaluate shortlisted candidates through in-person or virtual interviews. Before making a final decision, conduct background checks, call references, and ensure compliance with all legal requirements.

Manage Financial Operations

Before hiring your first employee, it’s crucial to ensure you have the proper accounting setup for payroll compliance. Determine the appropriate payment method, whether it’s a salary or hourly wages, and set up a reliable payroll system to process payments accurately and on time. Familiarize yourself with tax regulations and obligations related to employee payroll, ensuring you correctly withhold and remit taxes. Implement a reporting system to keep track of payroll expenses, deductions, and filings, as well as to maintain transparency and compliance with regulatory authorities. 

Making an Offer and Onboarding

Now it’s time to make an offer. Present a comprehensive compensation package that includes salary, benefits, and any other relevant perks to showcase your commitment to the candidate’s well-being and career growth within the organization. Upon acceptance, make a formal written offer detailing all terms and conditions. 

Following the candidate’s acceptance, ensure a smooth transition by going through an onboarding process that acclimates the new hire to the organization’s culture, policies, and responsibilities, setting them up for a successful and fulfilling journey with your nonprofit. Provide the new hire with all the necessary information to get started while also collecting the required details from them to ensure a smooth and seamless integration into the organization.

Provide Continuous Support

To ensure the success and growth of new hires, providing continuous support is paramount. Offer them access to resources and training that empower them to excel in their roles and contribute meaningfully to the nonprofit’s mission. Additionally, schedule regular check-ins to address concerns, offer guidance, and foster a sense of belonging within the organization, ultimately helping them become valued and engaged team members.

Is Your Nonprofit Ready to Hire? 

If your nonprofit needs an extra hand and has the resources and means, it’s probably time to hire your first employee. As the organization expands its impact and operations, bringing in the right team member can significantly contribute to its success and mission fulfillment. We realize this can be scary and exciting all at once, and we’re here to help. Contact us to get started with our experienced financial professionals.


Do You Struggle to Make Sense of Your Financial Statements?

Get our FREE GUIDE to nonprofit financial reports, featuring illustrations, annotations, and insights to help you better understand your organization's finances.

Get the free guide!


Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: