What a $15.6 Million Deficit Should Teach Every Nonprofit Board
Written The Charity CFO
A local municipal utility company just posted a 15.6 million dollar deficit. The city council is now debating whether to spend up to 350,000 dollars on a forensic audit to figure out what happened. Everyone’s first instinct is the same word: fraud.
Tosha Anderson, host of A Modern Nonprofit Podcast, thinks that instinct is wrong. And after 20 plus years working inside nonprofit finance, she has a pretty good track record of knowing where these stories actually lead.
The numbers behind the story
The utility in question, based in Saint Louis, spent through 5 to 7 years of planned capital investments in a two year window. Reserves that had been healthy enough to fund community projects a couple of years earlier were suddenly gone. And for roughly 18 months leading up to the collapse, financial reports stopped reaching the board entirely.
The excuse offered at the time was a system migration. It is a familiar one. Anyone who has lived through an accounting software transition knows it can genuinely slow down reporting for a month, maybe two. But it does not explain a year and a half of silence, and it does not explain why nobody in leadership stood up and said this is no longer acceptable.
That gap, between a reasonable delay and total silence, is where Tosha wants nonprofit leaders to focus their attention.
Why fraud usually isn’t the answer
Here is the part that surprises people. In Tosha’s experience, fraud is the least common explanation when a finance function goes quiet. It happens, and it is the kind of story that makes headlines when it does. But it is not the pattern she sees most.
What she sees instead falls into two categories, and one is far more common than the other.
The first, and by far the most frequent, is a finance director who is simply in over their head. The organization has grown, the complexity has grown, and the person’s skill set has not kept pace. They do not know how to say that to leadership, either because they are embarrassed or because they suspect, correctly, that admitting it puts their job at risk. So instead of asking for help, they go quiet.
The second, less common but still more likely than fraud, is a finance leader who has simply stopped doing the work. Tosha notes this one tends to show up clearly in the data. Accounting system login activity tells the story. A finance director who is showing up and grinding through a real backlog looks very different in the system logs than one who has checked out.
Fraud sits behind both of these in frequency. It happens. It is just not where Tosha would put her money first.
The mistake most boards make
There is a specific trap Tosha sees leadership fall into constantly: assuming a struggling finance function is a capacity problem, and solving it by adding a bookkeeper or an extra staff member underneath the struggling director.
If the real issue is a skill gap, more headcount under that person does not fix it. It just adds another layer of confusion to an already broken process. The fix for a skill issue is a skill issue conversation, not a staffing conversation.
This is uncomfortable, because it means the fix often starts with a direct, sometimes difficult conversation with the person already in the role. But avoiding that conversation is exactly what let an 18 month reporting gap turn into a 15.6 million dollar deficit.
What should have caught this early
Three things, run consistently, would have surfaced this problem long before it became a crisis.
Monthly financial reports on a fixed schedule. Not “when they’re ready.” A fixed date, every month, no exceptions. At The Charity CFO, clients get their close by the 15th of the month, every time, and if something is missing, that gets flagged in the report rather than used as a reason to delay the whole package.
A budget to actual comparison, especially for major capital investments. If a multi year capital plan is suddenly compressed into two years, a budget to actual review makes that visible almost immediately. It is one of the simplest tools available and one of the most consistently skipped.
A rolling cash flow forecast, ideally 12 months out. Profit and loss statements and balance sheets are useful, but cash is what actually keeps an organization running. A forward looking cash flow forecast would have shown this council exactly where their balance was headed, long before the account ran dry.
The leadership lesson underneath it all
Strip away the utility company and the dollar figures, and this story is really about one thing: what happens when leadership treats silence as easier than confrontation.
Nobody in that organization asked for the missing reports for a year and a half. Nobody escalated. Nobody brought in outside help to validate a hunch that something was wrong. The system migration excuse was allowed to stand, unchallenged, for far longer than it should have.
That is the real failure. Not a single bad actor, but a room full of people who let silence go unquestioned.
What to do if this sounds familiar
If you are a nonprofit leader, and you cannot remember the last time you saw a budget to actual report, or you have asked for financial statements and gotten a vague answer instead of a date, that is your signal. Do not wait for a forensic audit to tell you what a monthly report already would have told you.
Ask the direct question. Require a direct answer. And if you are not getting one, escalate it, whether that means your finance committee, an outside consultant, or a full performance conversation with the person in the role.
Most nonprofit finance breakdowns do not start with fraud. They start with silence, and with leadership deciding that silence was easier than the hard conversation. Do not let your organization be the next headline that proves the point.
Follow Us Online
Website: www.thecharitycfo.com
Instagram: @thecharitycfo
Facebook: /thecharitycfo
LinkedIn: / the-charity-cfo
TikTok: @thecharitycfo
Join our newsletter: https://go.thecharitycfo.com/l/995872/2025-02-24/6ldn1
Download The Charity CFO Financial Blueprint on our Resources page: https://www.thecharitycfo.com/resources
Check Out These Blogs
5 Warning Signs of Nonprofit Cash Flow Issues
3 Types of Nonprofit Fraud to Watch Out for Today
Need more than a CFO? Our bookkeeping services offer additional support, so you get full-spectrum financial leadership, all in one place.
